Awareness

Imposter syndrome, or: why success feels like a borrowed coat

Imposter syndrome is not a sign that you don't belong. It's actually a sign that you care, you're aware of gaps in your knowledge, and you have a functioning conscience. None of which is the problem.

4 min read·
Share
Imposter syndrome, or: why success feels like a borrowed coat

There's a particular feeling that comes with success for a lot of people. It's not quite joy, not quite pride. It's more like wearing a coat you borrowed from someone else — impressive coat, fits okay, but you spend the whole evening slightly convinced someone's going to notice it isn't yours.

That's imposter syndrome. And the deeply inconvenient truth about it is that it tends to visit the most capable people most often.

What is it, actually

Imposter syndrome is the persistent belief that your achievements are not fully deserved — that you've gotten here through luck, good timing, charming people, or an elaborate set of coincidences that could unravel at any moment. The feeling that if people really knew, if they saw behind the performance, they'd rescind the invitation.

It was first named in 1978 by psychologists Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes, who noticed it was particularly common in high-achieving women. (It has since been confirmed to be an equal-opportunity affliction, which is something, at least.)

The defining feature is the disconnect: external evidence of competence — the job, the degree, the result, the room you're in — and the internal experience of being an absolute fraud who stumbled into all of it.

Why capable people have it most

The logic sounds backwards, but it makes sense once you look at it closely.

People with low self-awareness tend not to know what they don't know. They move through the world with a confidence that is, in many cases, completely untethered from reality. (You've met them.)

People with high self-awareness are acutely conscious of the gaps in their knowledge. They understand how complex things actually are, which means they understand how much they don't yet understand. They can see the distance between where they are and where mastery might be.

This awareness is not a problem. It is literally the first requirement of growing. But it can, if left unexamined, start to look like evidence that they don't deserve to be where they are.

They're not frauds. They just know enough to know what fraud could look like.

The things that don't help

"Everyone feels this way" — true, but not useful when you're in it.

"Just believe in yourself" — structurally useless as advice for anyone who doesn't already do that.

"Think of all you've achieved" — the imposter brain will find a way to credit each achievement to circumstances outside yourself within about six seconds.

What also doesn't help: waiting until you feel confident before you act. Confidence, frustratingly, tends to be the result of acting, not the precondition.

What actually does something

Name the voice. The running commentary of "you don't belong here, they're about to find out" is a voice, not a fact. Naming it creates just enough distance to notice you can observe it — which means you are not entirely it.

Collect contradictory evidence deliberately. The imposter brain selectively remembers every mistake and attributes every success to luck. Deliberately, consciously building a record of what you actually did — where you made the call, had the idea, held the room — starts to create a competing narrative.

Tell someone. Not as a plea for reassurance, but as a reality check. There's something about saying "I feel like a complete fraud right now" out loud to a person who knows you that tends to reveal how different the gap is between your internal story and the observable one.

The borrowed coat feeling doesn't go away permanently. But at some point you start to notice it's actually your coat and you just forgot.

One last thing

Most people running the same room you're in are also wearing borrowed coats. They've just been wearing theirs longer. That's essentially the whole secret.

Go anyway.

Get essays when they're ready

No spam. No schedule. Just honest writing when there's something worth saying.

If this resonated — share it

The best way to support this work is to share it with someone who needs to read it.

InstagramShare
Keep reading
Awareness is one of the four threads in The Unicorn Journals
The Unicorn Journals
If this hit close to home — the book goes further. A lot further.
Read 3 chapters free →or buy on Amazon →

Comments
Leave a comment
Comments are moderated before publishing
The book
The Unicorn Journals
Get on Amazon →